Destroying World Order Book Review
author: Francis A. Boyle
Publisher: Clarity Press, Inc.(2004)
source: Emirates Center for Strategic Studies
Dr. Francis Boyle is a leading American expert in international law, a
human rights activist, and the author of Destroying World Order. He
unequivocally opposes what he views to be breaches of international law
in US policy. Since the events of 9/11, Boyle has been engaged in
continuous conflict with the Bush Administration's policies'foreign and
domestic'under the veil of the War on Terror campaign. In Destroying
World Order, he makes the legal argument against the US
neoconservatives' worldwide transgressions.
American 'Neutrality' and the Iran-Iraq War
Boyle begins his case with a 1986 legal study that sheds light upon the
US's approach to the Iran-Iraq War. He exposes the legislative pretext
of a deeply rooted American tradition'neutrality, laws on which date
back to the 1790s. In theory, the principle of neutrality served to
grant priority to US economic interests over that of political agendas,
by not limiting international trade to select partners.
In practice however, the US's policy of neutrality has never been very
neutral at all'ever. The Iran-Iraq War was no exception. Throughout the
war, the United States continued to supply Saudi Arabia, an Iraqi ally,
with military equipment. Iran viewed this as hostile. Subsequently, the
Reagan Administration characterized the Iranian hostage-taking as an act
of international terrorism. This impeded a rational US foreign policy
toward Iran sufficient to protect the US's legitimate security
interests. The US also lobbied to remove Iraq from the list of nations
that support international terrorism, so that Saddam Hussein's regime
could purchase dual-use nuclear technology, capable of being employed
towards military purposes. According international law, which is
premised upon sanctifying neutrality, these were aggressive actions.
Thereby, Iran, if so inclined, reserved the right to contest and dispute
these actions by declaring war against the US.
US War Crimes
Boyle, interestingly, provides readers with the transcript of a 1992
international war crimes symposium. The conference essentially put the
United States on trial for war crimes. In the aftermath of the 1991 Iraq
War, an international committee of inquiry investigated alleged war
crimes committed in Iraq by the US. In February of 1992, the committee
presented their findings before a War Crimes Tribunal, whose members are
made up of international judges and human rights activists. Charges were
brought against all senior members of George H.W. Bush's Administration.
The accusations focused on three particular breaches of international
law, similar to those at the Nuremberg War Crimes Tribunal, in addition
to violations of other far-reaching precedents. A Doctor of Law, Boyle
also recalls a case in which he was called to testify in the court
martial of an army doctor who refused to serve her duty in Iraq's 1990
prewar preparations. He attested that many international conventions
excused her actions. Regardless, the army captain was convicted,
dishonorably discharged, jailed for 15 months, and deprived of all her
end of service compensation. In 1991, Boyle also petitioned the UN
Secretary, accusing President George H.W. Bush and his entire
Administration of genocide. He called for the lifting of international
sanctions on Iraq and compensating the siege victims.
He analyzes the legal implication of humanitarian intervention, which
often 'justifies' contemporary wars. Boyle is of the belief that
humanitarian intervention is an overused excuse by the United Nations
and NATO members'whether in Yugoslavia, Afghanistan, or Iraq. He defines
humanitarian intervention to be a misleading concept and accuses
developed nations of taking advantage of developing nations, using
whatever means necessary to justify lengthy military occupations.
The Post 9/11 World
According to Boyle, the 2001 US-led war in Afghanistan can be described
as an "armed & illegitimate aggression," because evidence was
insufficient to prove the Taliban was involved in the 9/11 attacks. He
makes the same case against George W. Bush's Iraq War, adding personal
vendetta and greed. Boyle claims US incursions in Afghanistan and Iraq
illustrate the US Administration's plan to control the world's energy
sources. He goes further, hypothesizing that the US aims to "control the
energy and natural gas supply to Europe, Japan, and Asia, and thereby,
control the future of world economy." As a result of this alleged desire
to dominate the world's energy sources and economy, the powerful elite
in the US are destroying world order.
At a peace demonstration in October of 2002, Boyle launched a national
campaign to oust the George W. Bush Administration, in an effort to
deter the administration from going to war against Iraq. Despite his
failure, the case for impeachment was indeed made. A future case remains
open for posterity to spearhead.
The US Threat to World Peace
Is the world headed towards World War III? Boyle concludes by posing
that wonder. He speculates that the US possesses the military capability
and the audacity to initiate a first atomic strike. It also has the
capacity to neutralize any retaliation'be it from Russia, China, or
elsewhere. It is the only world nation to have a track record of
detonating a nuclear devise upon a civilian population. Boyle thereby
calls upon American citizens to organize a civil resistance movement
without resorting to violence with the aim of arresting 'criminal
activities' executed by high ranking officials in the US government.
Destroying World Order represents opposition to the US mainstream. It
sheds light on leftist intellectualism and its counterargument to that
of the far right, Christian fundamentalist movement. There are many
Americans that would prefer a more moderate stance towards Arab issues.
And despite the fact that such fringe elements often tend to be
unrelated to reality, the case for mobilizing US efforts towards a more
sympathetic US-Middle East policy remains open.
Back to Top
' Arab World Books